The cleanup at 5001 Penn Avenue South started in the basement, with three truckloads of soil. That came to 45 cubic yards of dirt pushed through the wall by a burst water main, and building owner Carroll Peterson told Southwest Voices that "it had to be removed by hand, in buckets." The pipe broke on February 13, 2025. It had been installed in 1922, and shutting off the water took four hours.
For people who live in Lynnhurst, 50th & Penn is the corner they share with Fulton. It's where you pick up a pizza, buy a bouquet or browse a used paperback on the way back from Lake Harriet. The damaged building is on the southwest corner, on the Fulton side of Penn. Its storefronts still set the mood for everyone who walks past.
Heading into the corner's second winter since the flood, one pattern stands out. The comeback is coming from names that already belonged here, and most of them are staying within a block of where they started.
What the Flood Took Off the Corner
Three businesses on the southwest corner didn't come back to their spaces. In late May 2025, Broders' Restaurants announced that Terzo, its Italian restaurant at 2221 W. 50th St., would not reopen. According to Bring Me The News, the family company said the time, energy and resources needed to rebuild were "beyond our capacity."
Sparrow Cafe had opened at 5001 Penn at the beginning of 2013. By July 2025, its owners had decided it couldn't reopen there without a major rebuild of the space. Paperback Exchange, at 2227 W. 50th St., had been on the corner for 50 years. The flood destroyed around 100,000 books across its basement and main floor.
Peterson put the damage to the building at about $1 million, and he said roughly 12% of it was covered by insurance. Ward 13 Council Member Linea Palmisano told Southwest Voices that the city's bridge department worked overnight for a week to build an underground support wall so restoration could go ahead.
Peterson credits the restoration firm RestPro with bringing the building back. Its crews hauled away 15 dumpster loads of wet material. By March 2026 all of the upstairs apartments were rented, and he told Southwest Voices he wanted retail tenants who "fit with the character and neighborhood."
Who Never Left
Theisen Renovation, the remodeling company at 5005 Penn, was the only tenant that stayed in the building through the repairs. Two neighbors in the same row, Lake Harriet Pizza at 5009 Penn and Lake Harriet Florist at 5011 Penn, were also on the list of damaged businesses. Both now list those Penn addresses with posted hours. The pizza shop's website has online ordering, and the florist's site is showing a fall collection.
Across the intersection, the Broders' family kept its other two rooms running. Bring Me The News reported in July 2025 that Broders' Cucina Italiana and Broders' Pasta Bar weren't damaged and stayed open across from Terzo. Today, the Cucina's website advertises breakfast every day starting at 8 a.m., with online ordering at 2308 W. 50th St. The Pasta Bar is at 5000 Penn Ave. S., and its ordering page lists an 11 a.m. opening time. On a winter weeknight, breakfast, Italian dinner, a pizza and flowers still come from the same intersection they did before February 2025.
A Boutique That Left Uptown in 2020 Chose the Flooded Building
One of the new names in the old building is a familiar one. Josh Sundberg and Delayna Payne founded Cliché in 2004 at 24th and Lyndale in Uptown. The shop was known for its "Crosswalk" fashion show, where styled models walked the crosswalks outside the store, and it was an early stockist for local labels like Larissa Loden and The Fitting Room.
Cliché closed in January 2020. Style writer Jahna Peloquin's September 22, 2026 roundup announced its return at 5001 Penn Ave. S. Sundberg is running the new store with his sister, Alicia Silva, and his wife, Erika Voeller. He promised a "cool girl meets coastal vibe," with labels including FRNCH, Muse Assembly, Marine Layer and Larissa Loden jewelry. The store's own site now reads "We're so back," with hours of 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. Tuesday through Saturday and noon to 5 p.m. on Sunday. It's closed Mondays.
5001 Penn is the address Sparrow Cafe used for twelve years. A shop that got its name in Uptown is now in the storefront Peterson spent a year restoring, and it's open in time for holiday shopping.
The Bookstore Is Moving One Block
The biggest return is still a few months off. Paperback Exchange opened in 1975 and built a collection of about 150,000 books before the flood damaged around two-thirds of the inventory. According to Mpls.St.Paul Magazine, the store plans to reopen in spring 2027 at 5000 Oliver Ave. S., a block from its old corner.
The new space is a single-family house. Co-owner Andy Hersey told the magazine it needs real work before it can open as a store, including an enlarged bathroom and an entrance that meets ADA standards. "It's going to take some time," he said. "We'd love to be open in the spring, for Independent Bookstore Day in April."
Hersey has worked at the store since the 1980s, and it has kept running small pop-up book events since the flood. The store's GoFundMe stood at $62,000 when the October 13, 2026 article was published. "People seem to be super excited about the bookstore coming back and the new space," Hersey told the magazine.
A bookstore in a converted house a block off the main corner will make the 50th & Penn walk a little longer, and it will add a stop on a residential block. For anyone in Lynnhurst who walks over from the east side of Penn, the route next spring will likely run past the Broders' corner, across to Cliché and the florist, then a block farther for books.
The Two Big Storefronts on 50th Street
The two largest storefronts on the 50th Street side are the former Terzo space at 2221 W. 50th St. and Paperback Exchange's old space at 2227 W. 50th St. In March 2026, Peterson told Southwest Voices that the bookstore space would be ready to rent within about two months and that work on the old Terzo space would follow. Whoever takes those two frontages will shape how the corner looks from the sidewalk.
The street work in the area isn't at this intersection. The City of Minneapolis's West Fulton neighborhood improvement project covers residential streets from France to Xerxes and from 47th to 54th, with work planned from 2025 through 2031. Its fall 2026 full-depth reclamation was scheduled for Chowen and Beard between 51st and 52nd streets.
If you're closer to Lake Harriet's other edges, our post on the festivals and bridge closures Lynnhurst shares with Tangletown covers the shared corners on that side of the neighborhood.
If you own near 50th & Penn and want to know how the corner's next tenants could affect your block, Doro Real Estate can help you think it through. Start your concierge consultation and we'll talk through your home and the blocks around Penn and 50th.